Deep Insight // Try thisAll worksheets  /  Chapter 8

Chapter 8: Staying the Course | Toolkit

Argument Analysis

The What, the Why, the Leap, the So-What. If the logic doesn't hold, neither does the conclusion.


Autosaves on this device PDF version

Our brains are wired to win arguments, not to find truth. This sheet slows you down long enough to test a claim, whether it came from a model, a colleague, or a conspiracy forum.

Part 1

The skeleton of an argument

PieceWhat it isBird example
The WhatThe claim or assertion someone wants you to believeBirds aren't real, they are government drones
The WhyThe evidence offered. Valid, cherry-picked, or missingBirds sit on power lines to recharge their batteries
The LeapThe hidden assumption. Disprove it and the argument falls apartOnly machines recharge, so birds must be machines
The So-WhatThe conclusion. Only works if everything above holdsTherefore, birds are drones

If you can't state it cleanly, you aren't ready to analyze it.

Part 2

Run the flowchart

Is there any evidence at all?
Does the evidence connect to the conclusion?
Do the hidden assumptions hold up?
Are there alternative explanations?
Part 3

Rewrite it honestly

Confidence in the ORIGINAL claim:
Bonus

Is your AI model misaligned?

Ask these before you rely on any AI output for classification, prioritization, or targeting.

Deep Insight: AI for the Intelligence Analyst by Rae Bakerdeepinsightbook.com